Bilawal warns of bloodshed over attempts to divide Sindh

bilawal-bhutto-warns-bloodshed-sindh-division

— PPP chairman questions motive behind Mohsin Naqvi’s referendum proposal, says constitutional procedure cannot be bypassed

–The attempt could trigger bloodshed and deepen political and social divisions

By Zulqernain

   Pakistan Peoples Party (PPP) chairman Bilawal Bhutto-Zardari has strongly opposed the proposal to hold a referendum on the creation of new provinces, warning that any attempt to divide Sindh against the wishes of its people could trigger bloodshed and deepen political and social divisions.

Responding to Interior Minister Mohsin Naqvi’s suggestion of a referendum to settle the debate over new provinces, Mr Bhutto questioned the motive behind repeatedly raising the issue without consulting political parties or taking it to parliament.

“I don’t know what my brother Mohsin is trying to do,” he remarked during a media interaction in Karachi, asking why the PPP and other political stakeholders had not been taken into confidence if the government was serious about creating new provinces.

He said the debate had been pushed for months without any formal discussion or decision in the federal cabinet or parliament.

While expressing the desire to see Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif succeed, he said the premier should at least have the authority to keep his ministers under control.

“If his own ministers undermine him, there should be no complaints about the system collapsing,” he added, in an apparent reference to Mr Naqvi’s repeated assertions that the existing administrative structure had failed.

The PPP chairman issued a particularly strong warning against any attempt to divide Sindh, saying the consequences could extend beyond Karachi to other parts of the province.

“If Sindh is divided forcibly, questions will be asked about the blood that will flow on the streets of Karachi,” he said, adding that such a move could create divisions in society that might eventually turn into hostility. “I do not want to see that bloodshed.”

Mr Bhutto maintained that the controversy was not really about holding a referendum but about the intentions behind the proposal.

 He argued that the Constitution already prescribed a procedure for creating new provinces and that looking for alternatives could create the impression of seeking an unconstitutional route.

“If you are looking for an unconstitutional way, the PPP cannot support you,” he said.

Mr Naqvi had first floated the idea of creating new provinces on July 30, arguing that the country’s existing administrative system had collapsed and needed restructuring.

 On Nov 12, he proposed a referendum, saying public opinion surveys suggested that a majority supported the creation of more provinces.

He said he would accept the public verdict if voters rejected the proposal, but the process of creating new provinces should move forward if they supported it.

The proposal has since triggered a wider debate within the ruling coalition, exposing differences over the constitutional and political implications of redrawing provincial boundaries.

Information Minister Attaullah Tarar defended the proposal, saying discussion on new provinces could not be stopped and that public opinion should be taken into account.

He questioned Mr Bhutto’s warning of bloodshed, arguing that the people’s wishes could not be ignored and a referendum was the best way to ascertain them.

Punjab Assembly Speaker Malik Ahmad Khan also backed the idea, suggesting that a referendum could raise complex constitutional questions if its outcome conflicted with the subsequent decision of a provincial assembly. He indicated that the matter might require interpretation by the Federal Constitutional Court.

Defence Minister Khawaja Asif, meanwhile, said political consensus on new provinces could be developed and suggested that a new administrative arrangement might emerge by the beginning of the new year. He also referred to the possible role of the Constitutional Court in resolving legal ambiguities surrounding the proposal.

However, the Constitution lays down a specific procedure for altering provincial boundaries. Under Article 239(4), a constitutional amendment seeking to change the limits of a province cannot be presented to the president for assent unless it has first been passed by the concerned provincial assembly with at least a two-thirds majority of its total membership. The amendment must subsequently secure the required two-thirds majority in both houses of parliament.

Article 48(6), meanwhile, provides for a referendum on a matter of national importance on the prime minister’s initiative, subject to approval by a joint sitting of parliament. But constitutional experts argue that a referendum cannot replace the legislative process prescribed for the creation of new provinces.

Former attorney general Ashtar Ausaf has maintained that a referendum may ascertain public opinion but cannot serve as an alternative to constitutional amendment or the approval required from the relevant provincial assembly.

The political sensitivity of the issue is particularly pronounced in Sindh, where the PPP has consistently opposed any division of the province. Bilawal’s latest remarks have therefore made it clear that the party is unwilling to accept a referendum as a shortcut to changing provincial boundaries, setting the stage for a potentially serious disagreement within the ruling coalition.

Leave a Reply