By Zain Khan Watozai
A heated exchange on X (formerly Twitter) has stirred debate in Pakistan’s political and journalistic circles, as Shahbaz Gill, former aide to ex-Prime Minister Imran Khan, found himself at the center of controversy for a derogatory post directed at journalist Asma Shirazi.
Gill shared a screenshot from a video of Shirazi and wrote a pointed remark questioning her choice of words. He further criticized her journalism as “X-rated” and implied that a similar response from him would deeply hurt her.
Asma Shirazi promptly responded, dismissing Gill’s comment with dignity: “It is neither my habit nor my upbringing to respond to shameless individuals in their language. But if you have the courage, share the video of my vlog.”
The tweet sparked immediate outrage, particularly from senior female journalists who condemned Gill’s behavior. One journalist called it “shameful” and highlighted that Gill regularly posts false information about journalists without any accountability, adding, “I hope PTI disassociates from such vulgar posts and behavior.”
As the controversy gained traction, PTI’s senior leader Zulfi Bukhari stepped in to denounce the remarks. In a statement, Bukhari emphasized, “I have requested him to delete it. NO, none of us stand by or justify such comments or behavior. Whether it happened to Bushra Bibi, Maryam Nawaz Sahiba, Asma Shirazi Sahiba, or any woman—it is all unacceptable. This behavior is disgusting and needs to end.”
The tweet has since been deleted, reportedly at Bukhari’s request. However, the incident highlights recurring issues of toxic behavior and personal attacks in Pakistan’s political discourse. Critics argue that such exchanges further polarize the country’s political and social fabric, particularly when they involve targeting women in public life.
For many, this episode is a stark reminder of the need for decency and accountability in political and journalistic interactions, as well as a call for political parties to take a firmer stance against such conduct within their ranks.
